The Church Courtyard > Non-Catholic Discussion Subforum

5 good reasons to become (or remain!) a Catholic Christian.

(1/3) > >>

I read two articles recently about Seminarians going through a period of trial in their Faith. One was over on CathInfo, the other was on One Peter Five:

A diocesan seminarian who struggled because of the Crisis:

So I wrote this article, for all who may be going through trials in their Faith, and also looking to evangelize non-Catholics to the Faith. 5 simple reasons. (links in the original)

"5 good reasons to become (or remain!) a Catholic Christian"

"Are you going through a time of trial in your Faith? Are you wondering if it is all worth it after all? Absolutely, it is worth it! There is a rich reward in Heaven waiting for you if only you persevere till the end. But you cannot do it on your own, you need the Grace of God, as we all do. Here are 5 good reasons why everyone should become, or remain, a Catholic Christian, designed especially for those struggling through a period of difficulty or dryness in their prayer life, a “dark night of the soul”.

I. Eucharistic Miracles – Signs and Proofs of Christ’s Divine Power to miraculously transubstantiate:

A non-Christian friend of mine called Eucharistic Miracles “the most powerful evidence for (Catholic) Christianity”. It is easy for us non-skeptics to understand why. For skeptics and doubters, these miracles serve as supernatural signs such that “in order that the submission of our faith should be in accordance with reason, it was God’s will that there should be linked to the internal assistance of the Holy Spirit external indications of His Revelation, that is to say divine acts, and first and foremost miracles and prophecies, which clearly demonstrating as they do the Omnipotence and Infinite Knowledge of God, are the most certain signs of revelation and are suited to the understanding of all.” (First Vatican Council, Dogmatic Constitution on the Catholic Faith: Chapter 3, On Faith).

Christ worked the wondrous Eucharistic Miracle of Lanciano in response to a poor Priest struggling through his own dark night. He wondered if Christ really was present in the Eucharist, as Christ had promised in the Gospel. In His Mercy, the Good Lord chose to answer the doubts of this “doubting Thomas” with a Eucharistic Miracle. It reminds us of His Post-Resurrection Apparition to St. Thomas.

The next time you are at Holy Mass, or Eucharistic Adoration, just remember the Living God is truly present in the Host. Some believe because they have seen. But blessed are those who believe even without seeing, as Our Lord said. Believing without seeing will merit a great reward in Heaven.

II. Marian Apparitions – Heavenly Reminders from Our Loving Mother of Her Maternal Presence

Non-Catholics, including Non-Catholic Christians, have become Catholic Christians thanks to Our Lady of Fatima’s Public Miracle of the Sun. 70,000 astonished eyewitnesses saw the Sun move and their clothes dry. Even the secular press reported it. These astonishing miracles do not happen outside the Catholic Faith. They are manifest evidence of a Supernatural Power. Fatima has been called the “Greatest Public Miracle since the Resurrection of Jesus”. It is a Great Grace God gave us!

To doubters and sceptics who try to explain away Fatima, a former Russian Orthodox Christian puts it like this: “The thing that initially triggered my move towards Catholicism is Our Lady of Fatima. One of my friends was telling me about the fruits Fatima had on her own life. She read what the Theotokos had said to the children about modesty, and it caused her to become more modest in her dress. She also told me about how her priest had visited Fatima and when he came back, he preached a fiery sermon about the reality of hell. I had been told by my fellow Orthodox Christians that Fatima was at best a hoax and at worst demonic, so I decided to investigate Fatima for myself.

The view that Fatima is simply a hoax cannot be the case. It has a miracle connected with it that was witnessed by thousands of people, many of whom were atheists who came to the event specifically to refute what the children were saying. Skeptics have argued that it was simply a mass hallucination, but Christians should be skeptical of this argument. Skeptics of the resurrection of Jesus often respond to the fact that there were 500 witnesses by pointing to Fatima. If Fatima was a mass hallucination, so could the resurrection of Jesus have been. No other mass hallucination has ever been recorded though. In reality, Fatima was actually the most seen public miracle since the time of the exodus about 3500 years ago.” Fatima is God’s Mercy revealed to a hurting fallen world.

Every day, as we pray Our Lady’s Rosary, we should thank God for the Grace of having been born Catholics, or having become such later on. Our Catholic Faith is the most Priceless Grace of our life!

Our Lady of Guadalupe’s Miraculous Tilma and Her marvelous conversion of 9 Million Souls is yet another miraculous proof of the Catholic Faith. Our Lady is one of the Most Successful Evangelists!

“Several trustworthy contemporary writers note that one missionary, a Flemish Franciscan named Peter of Ghent, baptized with his own hands over 1,000,000 Mexicans! “Who will not recognize the Spirit of God in moving so many millions to enter the kingdom of Christ,” wrote Fr. Anticoli, S.J., “and when we consider that there occurred no portent or other supernatural event … to attract such multitudes, other than the apparitions of the Virgin, we may state with assurance that it was the Vision of the Queen of the Apostles that called the Indians to the Faith.”

III. The Miraculous Shroud of Turin – Powerful Evidence of Our Blessed Lord’s Glorious Resurrection.

We cannot forget the Miraculous Proofs Our Lord gave of His own Resurrection – something that should console and edify all doubting Christians. Our Lord is unique among all people who have ever existed. Everyone else died and remained dead. He alone died and gloriously Rose again. There were more than 500 eyewitnesses to that historical fact. But the Shroud of Turin is a miraculous relic that gives even visible evidence of it. A recent study showed only a great burst of energy, more powerful than any laser on the market today, could have produced the Image of the Holy Face on the Shroud.

“The ultraviolet light necessary to [simulate the image] “exceeds the maximum power released by all ultraviolet light sources available today,” says Di Lazzaro. It would require “pulses having durations shorter than one forty-billionth of a second, and intensities on the order of several billion watts.” If the most advanced technologies available in the 21st century could not produce a facsimile of the shroud image, he reasons, how could it have been executed by a medieval forger?”

IV. 2000 Years of Saints and Martyrs for Jesus or His Church leading up to 2.5 Billion Christians.

Do you believe that Christianity is perishing, over and done-for? It is not. Maybe it’s time to broaden our outlook to Universal Christendom, to Global Christianity. There are, as of 2021, more than 2.5 Billion professing Christians in the world. Islam is a distant 2nd at less than 2 billion. Christianity is not going anywhere. It is going to remain the world’s most popular religion for a long time to come. Catholic Christianity leads all other Christian denominations combined at roughly 1.3 billion.

Do you think you’re having a hard time for your Faith? Well, according to Open Doors, some 340 million Christians experience high level of persecution for Christ. We cannot forget our brothers and sisters who are suffering for Christ’s sake. We should pray for and console one another, so that we can all prevail amidst our suffering. Through the Cross, we have victory.

We should respect all suffering Christians, as we respect soldiers who die for our country. But once more, Catholic Christianity has unique Saint-Martyrs like St. Padre Pio.

A Saint who lived crucified with Christ, who miraculously and mystically bore the Wounds of Christ like other Saints and Mystics going back to St. Catherine of Sienna and St. Francis of Assisi, St. Padre Pio suffered “White Martyrdom” like St. John the Apostle. He suffered more than enough to be a martyr, and his voluntary acceptance of suffering gained great graces for the Church.

St. Paul mentions a similar principle in Col 1:24. Where are the St. Padre Pios of today? It’s your chance and your choice, to be a spiritual son or daughter of St. Pio, and become like him.

V. The Crown of Glory waiting for you in Heaven. This Crown is granted to those who persevere.

St. Padre Pio was known for praying 150 to 250 decades of the Rosary during the day! 250 decades! No wonder he became a Saint. And he persevered in doing this for over 50 years. If you want to become a Saint, as St. Montfort also teaches, you can do so by praying the Rosary like he did.

St. Montfort: “Secondly, we should do this so that we ourselves may receive three crowns from Jesus and Mary. The first is a crown of merit during our lifetime, the second, a crown of peace at our death, and the third, a crown of glory in Heaven.

If you say the Rosary faithfully until death, I do assure you that, in spite of the gravity of your sins “you shall receive a never fading crown of glory.” (1 Pet 5:4) … “(Let) no man take thy crown”: take care that your crown is not stolen by somebody who has been more faithful than you in saying the Holy Rosary. It is “thy crown”—Almighty God has chosen it for you and you have already won it halfway by means of the Rosaries that you have said well. Unfortunately someone else may get ahead of you in the race—someone who has worked harder and who has been more faithful might possibly win the crown that ought to be yours, paying for it by his Rosaries and good works. All this could really happen if you stand still on the beautiful path where you have been running so well: “You did run well.”“Who hath hindered you?” Who is it who will have prevented you from having the Rosary crown? None other than the enemies of the Holy Rosary who are so numerous.”

Our Lord said, “Be thou faithful until death: and I will give thee the Crown of Life” (Apoc 2:10). Claim that Promise! Look forward to it in joyful hope and eager anticipation! If we are faithful unto death, Our Lord will, according to His Promise, give us the Crown of Life!

That should make us happy! We have something glorious to look forward to. Let us complete the 9 First Fridays to the Sacred Heart, the 5 First Saturdays to the Immaculate Heart, the Great Double Novena to the Twin Hearts together, pray the Rosary every day, wear the Scapular, and then we know that we will die in Grace, with the Sacraments of the Church, receive Final Perseverance and go to Heaven. We ought to live a blessed and happy life expecting this!

And should we evangelize? Of course! It is well said, and piously believed, that each soul we help bring to Jesus will be like a beautiful jewel on our eternal crown! What a thought! It should motivate us to try and bring multitudes to Jesus in the course of our lifetime. Each good work done with faith in Christ, by the Grace of God, merits an eternal reward. Truly, we are so blessed!

Hi Xavier - this post seems to be aimed at someone like me. I will respond with some thoughts of my own regarding the first 3 points, since I don’t know if 4 and 5 are supposed to be evidence

Regarding Eucharistic miracles and Marian apparitions, a non-Catholic Christian could cite this passage from the beginning of Deuteronomy 13:

If a prophet, or one who foretells by dreams, appears among you and announces to you a sign or wonder, 2 and if the sign or wonder spoken of takes place, and the prophet says, “Let us follow other gods” (gods you have not known) “and let us worship them,” 3 you must not listen to the words of that prophet or dreamer. The Lord your God is testing you to find out whether you love him with all your heart and with all your soul.

The interesting thing about this passage is that it doesn’t specify if the miracle is performed by God or some infernal spirit, so it might be that God performs miracles such that it may appear to confirm the infidel prophet, but that God is testing to see if His people will remain true to Him, and not deviate from true worship and doctrine

Now undoubtly some people will convert because of these miracles - just as some Catholics convert to Charismatic churches because of healings or an experience of directly encountering the Holy Spirit. I don’t think either case is sound if one should follow the counsel from Deuteronomy 13.

Regarding the Shroud of Turin - how does that prove Christ’s resurrection? If it’s an authentic relic, at best that would prove Christ’s human existence and that He died and was buried. But how does it in itself prove His resurrection?


--- Quote from: TheSaintsAreComing on June 06, 2021, 05:18:25 AM ---Hi Xavier - this post seems to be aimed at someone like me. I will respond with some thoughts of my own regarding the first 3 points, since I don’t know if 4 and 5 are supposed to be evidence

--- End quote ---

For what it's worth, my reaction as a convert to Catholicism was that nothing Xavier posted resonated with my experience of becoming Christian and Catholic.

I was born and raised in a Jewish family and stopped practicing Judaism in my early teens.  At 16 I became a Fundamentalist Christian.  At 21 I became Catholic.  In my 50s I deepened my Catholic faith by discovering the traditional Mass and devotional practices.  Miracles, apparitions, and promises of future heavenly rewards played no part in any of these experiences.

The one thing that moved me was a desire to come closer to God.  My first encounter with Christianity, among the Fundamentalists, although it exposed me to many errors, also taught me about a personal God who loved me and wanted to be in a relationship with me.  Later, when investigating Catholicism, I attended Mass and felt drawn to Christ's presence in the Eucharist.  Much later, stumbling upon traditional Catholicism, I found an even richer and more beautiful expression of faith.

I don't know if the sort of thing that Xavier was writing about makes a difference for most people, but it didn't for me.  It's not that I disbelieve in miracles and apparitions.  They just don't have much impact on my faith.

clau clau:'s%20wager%20is%20an%20argument,either%20exists%20or%20does%20not.


--- Quote from: clau clau on June 06, 2021, 10:59:14 AM ---'s%20wager%20is%20an%20argument,either%20exists%20or%20does%20not.

--- End quote ---

I never found this at all compelling either.  Before I was a Christian, I thought it would be better to go to hell than be in heaven with the sort of god who would send people to hell.


[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

There was an error while thanking
Go to full version