Whos banned from Fisheaters?

[Kaesekopf]

[Greg]

How did you get banned for defending the Jews?

[trentcath]

Ive not changed or couched anything I have posted previosly
.
I have not changed...if I get banned we know who changed

Its been obvious for ages, Tracy aint a trad, not even close and frankly given her bias  modding and allowing disgusting posts to go unchecked my opinion of her is very low.

Let's keep personal criticisms to a minimum.

That is the minimum.

[trentcath]

Adeodatus, it says under your name you were banned for "trad-bashing" or something similar.

Yeah, well the definition of that changes depending on what time of the month it is.

Some of the people who have been banned from FE I like, and some I don't. Some I agree with, and some I don't (and those groups don't necessary correlate). But who can actually figure out the 'moderation' over there? Well, c'est la vie.

Moderation at FE = moodswings #justsaying

[LouisIX]

A lot of us are old FE members.  It's a good thing we have a new home.

[tmw89]

Adeodatus, it says under your name you were banned for "trad-bashing" or something similar.

Yeah, well the definition of that changes depending on what time of the month it is.

Some of the people who have been banned from FE I like, and some I don't. Some I agree with, and some I don't (and those groups don't necessary correlate). But who can actually figure out the 'moderation' over there? Well, c'est la vie.

Moderation at FE = moodswings #justsaying

A lot of us are old FE members.  It's a good thing we have a new home.

Amen to both of these.

[Jayne]

Adeodatus, it says under your name you were banned for "trad-bashing" or something similar.

Yeah, well the definition of that changes depending on what time of the month it is.

Some of the people who have been banned from FE I like, and some I don't. Some I agree with, and some I don't (and those groups don't necessary correlate). But who can actually figure out the 'moderation' over there? Well, c'est la vie.

Moderation at FE = moodswings #justsaying

It is not really difficult to figure out why Adeodatus got banned.  Since you can not look at this yourself, I will post the relevant quotes.  He wrote: "Now, I know that these reasons will fall on deaf ears since your average trad hates America, hates Jews and hates the Pope. Like these dudes:" and showed a picture of Klansmen burning a cross. 

Vox replied:  "Adeodatus, you're banned for trad-bashing. Accusing the average trad of hating Jews and the Holy Father is disgusting and an egregious lie. Where do you think you are? Some newspaper's comments section?"

[voxxpopulisuxx]

Adeodatus, it says under your name you were banned for "trad-bashing" or something similar.

Yeah, well the definition of that changes depending on what time of the month it is.

Some of the people who have been banned from FE I like, and some I don't. Some I agree with, and some I don't (and those groups don't necessary correlate). But who can actually figure out the 'moderation' over there? Well, c'est la vie.

Moderation at FE = moodswings #justsaying

It is not really difficult to figure out why Adeodatus got banned.  Since you can not look at this yourself, I will post the relevant quotes.  He wrote: "Now, I know that these reasons will fall on deaf ears since your average trad hates America, hates Jews and hates the Pope. Like these dudes:" and showed a picture of Klansmen burning a cross. 

Vox replied:  "Adeodatus, you're banned for trad-bashing. Accusing the average trad of hating Jews and the Holy Father is disgusting and an egregious lie. Where do you think you are? Some newspaper's comments section?"

Thank you jayne at least your your little black quote book came in handy this time. Adeodatas is putting a very positive spin on his banning. Him and I had pmflames and he is not as nice as he pretends....like you kinda only male.

[Jayne]

Thank you jayne at least your your little black quote book came in handy this time. Adeodatas is putting a very positive spin on his banning. Him and I had pmflames and he is not as nice as he pretends....like you kinda only male.

It is normal for people to see themselves in a positive light.  I'm sure that you do too.  As for me, I think that I am a cute little kitten. 

I had a lot of misgivings about posting those FE quotes, but finally decided that I ought to do it because it would best serve the truth.  Adeodatus deserves a fresh start on SD and should be judged here on how he behaves here, just like everyone else. 

[Lateran]

Thank you jayne at least your your little black quote book came in handy this time. Adeodatas is putting a very positive spin on his banning. Him and I had pmflames and he is not as nice as he pretends....like you kinda only male.

I had a lot of misgivings about posting those FE quotes, but finally decided that I ought to do it because it would best serve the truth.  Adeodatus deserves a fresh start on SD and should be judged here on how he behaves here, just like everyone else.

There is a Logic Error in that post.

[Mithrandylan]

With the nature of the internet, a person should be viewed on what they say.  It's the only way to view them.  If someone stands by something they said, that is how they ought to be viewed.  The venue in which something is said is irrelevant.  If, for example, a poster was found to be elsewhere on the internet causing scandal and recommending sin, they shouldn't have a 'safe spot' that they can go to.  We should not compartmentalize our persons.  Public statements have public consequences.  Obviously we forgive transgressions, but we do right to be careful around those who do not apologize for them or repudiate them.  In the case at hand, we have a poster on the record making an ignorant broad brush smear against traditionalists and conflating them with a hate group.  I can't imagine why such a person would want to even have an account on a site like this, but it should come as no surprise if posters aren't wary of such a person's presence. 

[Jayne]

With the nature of the internet, a person should be viewed on what they say.  It's the only way to view them.  If someone stands by something they said, that is how they ought to be viewed.  The venue in which something is said is irrelevant.  If, for example, a poster was found to be elsewhere on the internet causing scandal and recommending sin, they shouldn't have a 'safe spot' that they can go to.  We should not compartmentalize our persons.  Public statements have public consequences.  Obviously we forgive transgressions, but we do right to be careful around those who do not apologize for them or repudiate them.  In the case at hand, we have a poster on the record making an ignorant broad brush smear against traditionalists and conflating them with a hate group.  I can't imagine why such a person would want to even have an account on a site like this, but it should come as no surprise if posters aren't wary of such a person's presence.

Fair enough.

[Adeodatus]

The "your average Trad" part is caustic and meant to show my continuing disappointment and disgust with things that I read Trads saying online. It is meant to sound accusatory.

I don't mind Jayne quoting it. I do not apologize for it, retract it or feel the least bit bad about it. Every time I see Internet Trads slam on the Pope, the Jews or my country I feel exactly the same way. There's no point in saying it here, though. I doubt very many Catechumens read this site. As for Vox, she says one thing and does another. I don't consider her behavior to be consistent.

In real life, I've only ever met one Trad whose views or behavior were even 10% as odious as those I see every day on the Internet. I'm not sure what the disconnect is, but it exists. I think if the average attendee at my diocesan TLM read some of this stuff they'd be as appalled as I am.

Well, except in actual fact I'm a Jew and a semi-retired Mossad agent. Mith finally Perry Masoned it out of me. I admit it. My op with Mossad was to make sure that Steve Guttenberg had a successful acting career. We were grooming him to become the next Pope. Obviously things didn't pan out and I had the option of either carrying out political assassinations in Damascus or becoming an Internet Psyop Specialist aimed at tricking Catholics into not hating the Jews. The Damascus thing payed better but I can't stand tabbouleh so I decided to do the Internet thing. I guess that hasn't panned out either. Maybe the ADL is hiring.

[Greg]

@Adeodatus You should get banned at Cathinfo.  It would take less time and effort than at Fisheaters.

[Archer]

In real life, I've only ever met one Trad whose views or behavior were even 10% as odious as those I see every day on the Internet. I'm not sure what the disconnect is, but it exists. I think if the average attendee at my diocesan TLM read some of this stuff they'd be as appalled as I am.

True statement. I would even extend it to your average attendee at ANY Trad Chapel (FSSP, SSPX, SSPV etc.) The anonymity the internet provides often leads to hot headed and offensive statements made in the name of charity and "instructing the ignorant."

A wise man on another forum once said that before he logs on he always says three Hail Mary's to help him post charitably.  If more of us did this and posted like we would talk in the Church Courtyard after Mass on Sundays then maybe we could bridge the gap between online and real life.