Whos banned from Fisheaters?

[Ben]

Ben, who are you?

I'm Ben. 

[tmw89]

Ben, so far, the people who were "snarky" and "disrespectful" were, to my knowledge, either SSPX or sedevacantist types.

Bombay, of course, enjoys full immunity to say whatever he wants to whomever he wants. Need I remind anyone about his screed against VoxPop, instructing him to commit an unnatural vice on someone and then blow his own brains out?

That kind of behavior over there is tolerated and permitted; it speaks volumes about the Catholicity of that forum.  The place can't pretend to be Traditional or Catholic in anything but an ironic sense.

[Jayne]

why is it dishonrable if your not allowed to criticise it there..

It is dishonourable to accept the benefits of FE while talking crap about it elsewhere.  If you think it so terrible leave. 

[Jayne]

Now that you know Vox knows.

I thought about telling her and decided it would be dishonourable.

I'm deciding whether to believe you.

I do not lie and I do not sneak.  As far as forums go, my first allegiance is to Fish Eaters.  If I see something here that I deem a thread to it, I will oppose that threat.  I will, however, do so openly.

If KK thinks that I ought to be banned for that, then I will accept his judgment without complaint.

[voxxpopulisuxx]

why is it dishonrable if your not allowed to criticise it there..

It is dishonourable to accept the benefits of FE while talking crap about it elsewhere.  If you think it so terrible leave.

So you equate criticism with talking crap...hmmmm interesting. And why would I have to leave? And the Benefits of FE? And these benefits other than its just a good internet forum with interesting folk and topics....is there something else...something sancrosanct...something beyond criticism?...Is there a health plan...profit sharing...free ice cream?

[Archer]

why is it dishonrable if your not allowed to criticise it there..

It is dishonourable to accept the benefits of FE while talking crap about it elsewhere.  If you think it so terrible leave.

What benefits are we accepting exactly? And where is this imaginary rule coming from? Last time I checked people are free to be members of whatever forum they want as long as they follow the rules which are enforced by the forum owner and moderators.   

If you don't like how people talk here, then by your own reasoning you should leave. 

[Gottmitunsalex]

Now that you know Vox knows.

I thought about telling her and decided it would be dishonourable.

I'm deciding whether to believe you.

I do not lie and I do not sneak.  As far as forums go, my first allegiance is to Fish Eaters.  If I see something here that I deem a thread to it, I will oppose that threat.  I will, however, do so openly.

If KK thinks that I ought to be banned for that, then I will accept his judgment without complaint.

In all reality, if he does ban you, you won't have any other choice.

I recall some posters who used the same words as you did in your first paragraph in FE, with regards to being opposed to sedevacantism and "oppose that threat" etc..They got banned.

 

[Archer]

Now that you know Vox knows.

I thought about telling her and decided it would be dishonourable.

I'm deciding whether to believe you.

I do not lie and I do not sneak.  As far as forums go, my first allegiance is to Fish Eaters.  If I see something here that I deem a thread to it, I will oppose that threat.  I will, however, do so openly.

If KK thinks that I ought to be banned for that, then I will accept his judgment without complaint.

I think you're out of line.  You are not the police of every forum and you are not Fisheater's knight in shining armor.  Vox does not need you to defend her honor at every opportunity across the entire internet. 

[Gottmitunsalex]

why is it dishonrable if your not allowed to criticise it there..

It is dishonourable to accept the benefits of FE while talking crap about it elsewhere.  If you think it so terrible leave.

What benefits are we accepting exactly? And where is this imaginary rule coming from? Last time I checked people are free to be members of whatever forum they want as long as they follow the rules which are enforced by the forum owner and moderators.   

If you don't like how people talk here, then by your own reasoning you should leave.

[trentcath]

why is it dishonrable if your not allowed to criticise it there..

It is dishonourable to accept the benefits of FE while talking crap about it elsewhere.  If you think it so terrible leave.

Oh please, criticising isn't 'talking crap', grow up and stop being so childish and over-defensive, all the complains so far posted are legitimate. Frankly I think its disgusting I get banned for meanness but Dr Bombaby gets to insult priests, blaspheme, use horrific language etc... and all with impunity. Does anyone know why Dr Bombaby gets away with this?

[trentcath]

Now that you know Vox knows.

I thought about telling her and decided it would be dishonourable.

I'm deciding whether to believe you.

I do not lie and I do not sneak.  As far as forums go, my first allegiance is to Fish Eaters.  If I see something here that I deem a thread to it, I will oppose that threat.  I will, however, do so openly.

If KK thinks that I ought to be banned for that, then I will accept his judgment without complaint.

I think you're out of line.  You are not the police of every forum and you are not Fisheater's knight in shining armor.  Vox does not need you to defend her honor at every opportunity across the entire internet.

It is a bit pathetic.

[Jayne]

What benefits are we accepting exactly? And where is this imaginary rule coming from?

I am not talking about a rule.  I am talking about honour.  Some people have a sense of honour that acts as a guide to their behaviour.

[trentcath]

What benefits are we accepting exactly? And where is this imaginary rule coming from?

I am not talking about a rule.  I am talking about honour.  Some people have a sense of honour that acts as a guide to their behaviour.

Oh lord, do I have to put up with this sanctimonius preaching here as well? Don't think I've forgotten about you claiming 'I  dont understand how you can call yourself catholic' for pointing out the popes errors and then saying it was a 'misunderstanding'

[tmw89]

All in favor of an anti-mini-modding amendment to the Forum Rules, please let me know by replying "Ay!" to this post.  Thanks.

[Jayne]

If KK thinks that I ought to be banned for that, then I will accept his judgment without complaint.

In all reality, if he does ban you, you won't have any other choice.

I have a choice about whether I complain about it.  If KK bans me, I will not say anything against him for doing so.