Interview with Fr. Paul Morgan on why he left the SSPX

[matt]

Introduction

I am Father Paul Morgan, ordained by Bishop Lefebvre at Ecône in 1988. After that, I was 4 years in the district house in London as an assistant. Following this, I was the 1st Superior of the Society of St. Pius X in the Philippines for 4 years, until 1996. Then 2 years as a school principal at St Mary's School in England and then 5 years as a prior at Post Falls in Idaho, USA. And then 12 years as district superior of Great Britain, Ireland and Scandinavia, until 2015. Then sabbatical year at Montgardin, which I had asked for. And then 2016-2017, Prior in Vancouver, Canada.

What is your current situation?

Right now, I am outside the Society, since I resigned on August 9 of this year [2017] because of the marriage affair.

Why did the marriage affair make you quit?

It seemed to me, it always seems to me, that it is an essential compromise to accept the principle that priests representing modern dioceses come to us, in the bastionsof Tradition, to receive the promises of the bride and groom. Even if in practice we are a little restricted in such things, we have accepted the principle. And that's why, in concrete terms, I wrote my letter of resignation.

Why react now?

I think there were many of us, quite a few priests and superiors themselves, who had reacted against the new way of doing things, even before the 2012 chapter. There were many of us in Albano in 2011 to say to Bishop Fellay, very respectfully, that these steps should not be continued in order to reach an agreement with modernist Rome. So, we have already done a great deal in the Society, among ourselves, with the superiors to denounce and oppose these approaches. For example, in 2012, the district of Great Britain was ready, in its entirety, to break away if they made a false agreement with modernist Rome. So it is not just this year that we have begun to react, but we have already for years.

Why didn't you react publicly?

I think the manifesto, the statement of the 7 deans and superiors of friendly communities in France, was very, very well put. So publicly, that was already explained. And I can also say that I have done things in order and according to the rules, by sending a manifesto signed by several priests from Canada to Bishop Fellay and to Menzingen, explaining quite simply, the serious problems with these new directives for receiving marriage vows. So right away we talked about it on the Internet, so it became public, etc.. So, I chose to do things that way. Now, I speak more publicly, since I've had a little time to organize myself - and we left Canada with a suitcase in our hands, not knowing where to go because we never thought of being alone, on the outside like that.

What prospects for the 2018 General Chapter?

Unfortunately, I do not have much hope in the general chapter next year. It seems to me that with the change of minds that has been taking place for several years now - so that we think that Rome is now kind, Rome loves us, we can make an agreement or do more good saying inside the Church, s if we were outside the Church until now, it's unbelievable, isn't it - so I don't have much hope. And we can see that good priests like the 7 deans, for example, who have made a very good document - and a special hello to Father de la Rocque in exile in the Philippines, a country that I like very much but which is still in exile - we see what happens to priests who denounce problems respectfully and rightly: we punish them! So I think the superiors in the chapter will simply do what Menzingen tells them to do.

What about your apostolate?

At the moment, I have no official apostolate. I am in contact with a lot of priests, in France and abroad, as well as with the faithful, encouraging and supporting them. Aslo with priests who have left [the SSPX] already a few months or a few years ago, for reasons that are in the end quite similar.

It is very encouraging to see the strong religious communities in France, religious men and women. I am in contact with them but I understand that this is a difficult situation for these communities, which may be at risk of sanctions if they show themselves too publicly in agreement with priests like myself.

Nevertheless, we celebrate Mass, we pray, we visit confreres, we have been able to preach a retreat already, we have made visits on the right and on the left. I get a lot of invitations from other countries to come and help. But at the moment, for rather practical matters we have to organise ourselves before embarking on any future activities. But I think, it seems to me that in June-July 2018, we are going to shoot into action. I think there will be more positive reactions in the coming year.

In connection with the bishops consecrated by Bishop Williamson?

Yes, if need be, of course, since we need bishops for Sacred orders and confirmations. Consecrating bishops in this emergency, as Archishop Lefebvre himself had said, can be repeated. This is not something reserved exclusively for Archbishop Lefebvre. And yes, we are quite willing to collaborate with the faithful, with faithful Catholics.

In conclusion?

I conclude by saying that we always have hope in the Good Lord. I think of Archbishop Lefebvre who was alone. He resigned some the Holy Ghost Fathers so as not to have any part in the destruction of his congregation. So priests like him and certainly many others, did this for important reasons. Let us try to make contacts, to gather together in order to help other priests who, for the moment, remain within the Society, hoping to organize something to help them as also [to help] the sound faithful. There's a lot of work to be done. We have hope.

And then, finally, Our Lady of Fatima spoke about diabolic disorientations. It seems to me that what is happening here is an example, right here in 2017, [an example] of this confusion of mind. So, as Archishop Lefebvre said, we must remain faithfully, we must keep the principles of the fight for the faith, the good fight and then, if we have to suffer by doing this, God's Holy will must be done.

[matt]

"For example, in 2012, the district of Great Britain was ready, in its entirety, to break away if they made a false agreement with modernist Rome. So it is not just this year that we have begun to react, but we have already for years."

Yes, thanks for admission Fr. Morgan, your threats of withholding the sacraments to those who sort to expose your scheming at that time, and the personal, confidential information on a certain individual that you passed on to an SSPX employee that was subsequently leaked onto the internet (we have forensic evidence linking all of this. We had developed a system that could get the IP address of Forum posters on IA, CI, ABLF, and that being used by the Carmel Books manager, remember that email you received before you flew out to Italy???), but none of what you say didn't and wouldn't have transpired thanks to the efforts of Mr. Gerry Gables, Searchlight Magazine, Damien Thompson, Catholic Herald, and those faithful who collaborated in exposing what was occurring in the SSPX GB District at that time. Thanks to all who prevented this, especially the "Mr. Men"!

God bless Mr. Gables!


Incidentally Fr. Morgan, what you object to has been going on in France for years. I have the word of a French priest that at least two of those Deans performed the same act - accepting a diocesan witness - that you object to!

[Carleendiane]

Dear Father, please, pray for us, trying so hard to  make sense of the world and church we are born and baptized into. We are just struggling to uphold all teaching of the ages. We look to carry the standard of our church. The moral/theological standard of the church of old, as we know it. Please pray for us as we make our way through the quagmire of recent verbage, dumped upon us from the church of open doors. The church without judgement and church of acceptance. Oh God, please, help us!

[diaduit]

Matt, if searchlight is your friend then you are not my friend. Searchlight are anti Catholic and metaphorically speaking they're like a journalistic version of antifa

[Lynne]

Following...

Fear makes a person (priest) do crazy things...